Newsletter · November 2026
GOP Lawmakers Who Sought to Overturn Proposition 12 Suffer Major Election Defeats
Republicans who backed efforts to overturn voter-approved farm animal welfare laws lost key congressional races in Iowa, Minnesota, North Carolina and other states.
A substantial number of Republican lawmakers who sought to overturn Proposition 12, California’s landmark farm animal welfare law, suffered a series of defeats in the Nov. 3 midterm elections, delivering a significant victory for animal protection advocates and supporters of states’ rights and further imperiling the chances of success for proponents of repeal.
Nineteen Republican lawmakers and candidates associated with efforts to repeal Proposition 12 lost their elections or primaries, including 10 members of the House Agriculture Committee.
The losses were particularly pronounced in Iowa, Minnesota and North Carolina, the nation’s three leading pork-producing states, where Republican lawmakers had been among the most vocal supporters of legislation aimed at overturning state farm animal welfare protections.
At the center of the controversy was the Save Our Bacon Act, commonly called the SOB Act, which would override California’s Proposition 12 and Massachusetts’ Question 3. Both voter-approved measures prohibit extreme confinement of farm animals, most notably gestation crates, which are so narrow that breeding sows cannot turn around, and restrict sales of pork from operations that don’t meet their standards, regardless of where the animals were raised.
The SOB Act has been championed by the National Pork Producers Council and Smithfield Foods, the largest U.S. pork producer, which is owned by China’s WH Group.
High-profile Republican losses
Among the most consequential defeats was that of Rep. Ashley Hinson of Iowa, the House sponsor of the SOB Act, who lost her bid for the U.S. Senate seat being vacated by Republican Sen. Joni Ernst. Ernst, who did not seek reelection, had led efforts to advance the legislation in the Senate. Hinson was defeated by Democrat Josh Turek, an outspoken opponent of the SOB Act.
Three additional Iowa Republicans lost their races: Reps. Zach Nunn and Mariannette Miller-Meeks, along with congressional candidate Joe Mitchell, who sought Hinson’s former House seat. In neighboring Minnesota, Rep. Brad Finstad, a vocal critic of Proposition 12, also appeared to lose his reelection bid. Finstad represented the state’s largest pork-producing congressional district.
North Carolina experienced a similar wave of Republican defeats. Reps. Richard Hudson, Brad Knott, Virginia Foxx, Tim Moore, Greg Murphy, and Addison McDowell lost their races.
In another North Carolina race, Democrat Jamie Ager defeated Republican Jennifer Balkcom, who replaced Rep. Chuck Edwards as the Republican candidate after Edwards withdrew from his reelection campaign in August. Edwards also had opposed Proposition 12.
An All Life Institute-affiliated organization, Animal Wellness Action, mounted major campaigns against two additional Republican lawmakers, Reps. Rob Bresnahan of Pennsylvania and Derrick Van Orden of Wisconsin, citing their votes to repeal Proposition 12 and their reneging on a public pledge to back an intact FIGHT Act, legislation targeting dogfighting and cockfighting. Both lost: Bresnahan to Democrat Paige Cognetti and Van Orden to Democrat Rebecca Cooke.
By contrast, Reps. Anna Paulina Luna of Florida and Andrew Garbarino of New York, both prominent Republican supporters of Proposition 12, won reelection.
The defeated lawmakers’ positions on animal welfare and states’ rights compounded the political headwinds Republicans faced nationally, according to Wayne Pacelle, president of the Center for a Humane Economy, Animal Wellness Action and the All Life Institute. “I cannot think of a national election where animal issues resonated so significantly,” he wrote in a recent blog.
A decade-long battle over farm animal welfare
California voters approved Proposition 12 in 2018, following Massachusetts voters’ approval of Question 3 in 2016. Together, the measures received over 10 million votes.
The pork industry has repeatedly challenged the laws, including before the U.S. Supreme Court. In 2023, the court upheld California’s authority to enforce Proposition 12, rejecting a constitutional challenge brought by pork industry groups.
Despite that ruling, Rep. Glenn Thompson of Pennsylvania, the Republican chairman of the House Agriculture Committee, has continued pushing to include a provision repealing Proposition 12 in a final farm bill.
However, with numerous supporters of the Save Our Bacon Act defeated, animal protection advocates see the election results as a warning to lawmakers seeking to override state animal welfare laws.
“The 10-year attack on farm animal welfare ballot measures is, for all practical purposes, over,” Pacelle said.
The election outcomes do not prevent Congress from revisiting the issue. But they represent a substantial political setback for efforts to overturn laws approved by millions of voters and a major win for organizations working to protect farm animals and preserve states’ authority to establish animal welfare standards.
For more information on the All Life Institute’s efforts to defend Proposition 12, see this blog by economist Galina Hale, Ph.D., who analyzed the proposed legislation through an economic lens. Hale is a professor of economics and coastal science and policy at the University of California, Santa Cruz.
For a detailed analysis of Proposition 12, see our report from January 2026 by Animal Wellness Action and the Center for a Humane Economy, authored by All Life Institute in-house scholars Svetlana Feigin, Jim Keen and Thomas Pool, with economic analysis informed by Hale’s research.
