Newsletter · November 2026
Amendment 83 Defeated in Colorado: Scholars Deployed with Effect in Landmark Victory
A decisive victory against a well-funded effort to rewrite Colorado’s constitution and weaken decades of wildlife protections.
There are moments in life that are truly euphoric. To learn within 30 minutes of the polls closing in Colorado on Nov. 3 that our collective efforts to defeat Amendment 83 had succeeded was surely one of those moments. We won — not by a hair’s breadth, but by a decisive 10-point margin — against a formidable, well-funded, highly organized opposition network that had spent two years plotting to jam “right to hunt” language in the Colorado Constitution.
The victory was especially remarkable given the circumstances. Proponents, led by Colorado hunting and trapping advocate Dan Gates and backed by wealthy national hunting organizations, had been preparing their campaign since 2024. Our intensive campaign began just 50 days before Election Day. Despite being outspent by more than three to one, we built a broad coalition of supporters, including wildlife scientists, healthcare experts, legal scholars, fair-chase hunters, Colorado Parks and Wildlife commissioners, and concerned citizens who successfully defended Colorado’s wildlife and democratic institutions.
The final tallies revealed the strength of our wide-ranging support and our fast-moving, multifaceted campaign: 54.9% voted against the measure, while 45.1% supported it. The opposition failed to garner the 55% required to amend Colorado’s constitution.
The defeat of Amendment 83 was a landmark victory for wildlife protection, science-based management, and the principle that Colorado’s wildlife belongs to all Coloradans, not just those who hunt and trap it.
What was Amendment 83 really about?
Amendment 83 was promoted as a common-sense measure to protect the right to hunt and fish. But hunting and fishing were already legal, protected and regulated in Colorado.
So why propose a constitutional amendment at all?
Dan Gates, the opposition leader for YES on 83, and well-heeled national hunting and trapping groups backing Amendment 83 sought to amend the Colorado Constitution to establish a constitutional right to hunt and trap using the vaguely defined “traditional methods.” The amendment also sought to establish hunting and trapping as the “preferred” means of managing wildlife, while preserving the state’s authority to regulate these activities only “if necessary” for sound scientific wildlife management.
The proposed amendment’s noticeably vague language concerned three legal scholars at the All Life Institute, who supported our campaign by writing separate public letters opposing Amendment 83 this fall.
“Amendment 83 has noticeably vague language. Even as a law professor, I cannot make sense of what this amendment would prohibit and allow. The amendment would enshrine a right to use ‘traditional methods.’ But what does this mean? Traditional as of 2026? Or traditional as of 1876 (when Colorado became a state)?” asks Justin Marceau, professor of law and Brooks Institute Faculty Research Scholar of Animal Law and Policy at the University of Denver Sturm College of Law.
Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission Chair Jay Tutchton characterized Amendment 83’s potential legal consequences as a “lawyer bonanza,” with wildlife management increasingly decided through lawsuits rather than science-based decision-making.
The vagueness of language was no minor drafting omission. It created an opening for litigation that could have threatened decades of wildlife protections and constrained future policymaking, transferring power from the existing democratic process of wildlife management to one that managed wildlife through the court system.
What Was at Stake for Colorado’s Wildlife and for Coloradans?
Three fundamental protections were at risk.
1. Preserving Decades of Hard-Won Wildlife Protections
Colorado voters have repeatedly demonstrated their willingness to protect wildlife from particularly cruel and unsporting practices.
In 1992, nearly 70% of voters approved a landmark initiative prohibiting spring bear hunting, bear baiting, and hunting bears with packs of hounds. These restrictions reflected concerns about fair chase, animal protection, and the vulnerability of female bears with dependent cubs.
In 1996, Colorado voters approved Amendment 14, restricting steel-jawed leghold traps, snares, and certain other trapping methods. These devices can inflict severe injuries and prolonged suffering on captured animals, including nontarget wildlife and pets.
In 2020, the Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission itself prohibited wildlife-killing contests targeting species such as coyotes and prairie dogs.
Dan Gates, a commercial trapper himself, explicitly told the Cowboy State Daily that he was pushing the amendment to bring back bear baiting, hound hunting and spring bear hunting in the state.
Amendment 83 could have provided a constitutional basis for challenging these established protections. CPW Commissioner Rich Reading warned that the measure threatened to undermine decades of wildlife management decisions. Its defeat safeguarded years of progress against cruel and indiscriminate wildlife-killing practices.
2. Protecting Future Wildlife Reforms
Amendment 83 could have also undermined future wildlife protection efforts advanced by Colorado voters, state lawmakers and CPW commissioners. Reforms such as restricting toxic lead ammunition; hunting mountain lions with GPS-radio collared hounds; or killing bobcats for their fur could have faced costly legal challenges, potentially making them difficult, if not impossible, to enact.
Attorney Jess Beaulieu, Colorado Parks and Wildlife commissioner and assistant director of the Animal Law Program at the University of Denver Sturm College of Law reiterates the importance of flexibility in wildlife management and how norms change over time: “Colorado’s history shows why that flexibility matters. Voters have repeatedly revisited which wildlife practices they are willing to tolerate, banning bear baiting and hounding and spring bear hunting in 1992, and restricting leghold traps, poisons, and snares in 1996. Amendment 83 would give the current preferences of a minority of Coloradans, and powerful out-of-state interests, constitutional force, obstructing future democratic debate,” she states.
3. Defending Democratic Control of Wildlife Management
Amendment 83’s defeat undoubtedly safeguarded decades of hard-won wildlife protections achieved in the past and preserved an open door for future reforms. Perhaps equally as important, our win preserved Colorado’s established system of wildlife governance.
Colorado’s wildlife is a public resource held in trust for all its citizens. Its management involves Colorado Parks and Wildlife (CPW), the CPW Commission, elected lawmakers, and, when necessary, Colorado voters acting through ballot initiatives.
These institutions provide a system of public accountability in which hunters, anglers, wildlife watchers, hikers, campers, photographers, and other citizens can participate. Amendment 83 threatened to disrupt this system by giving hunting and trapping interests preferential constitutional standing.
The victory preserved the authority of voters, lawmakers and wildlife professionals to make wildlife management decisions based on science, animal welfare and the public interest.
Strategies We Used to Defeat Colorado’s Amendment 83
How did we win against seemingly insurmountable odds?
Amendment 83 proponents poured money into campaign coffers, especially in the final two weeks of the campaign when their internal polling showed support for 83 cratering. Amendment 83 supporters spent $3.5 million, compared with roughly $1 million spent by the No on 83 side. Animal Wellness Action and the Center for a Humane Economy contributed close to $800,000 in support of this win. We were outspent by more than 3-to-1, yet we prevailed despite the enormous disparity.
Wayne Pacelle, president of Animal Wellness Action and the Center for a Humane Economy, aptly wrote this header in his Nov. 1, 2026, blog: “Money Alone Does Not Buy Elections.” Wayne continued, “There is an enormous coalition of wildlife scientists, Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commissioners, legal scholars, civic and good government organizations, newspaper editorial boards, gun safety groups, public-lands advocates, and conservation, animal welfare, and responsible hunting groups opposing this overreaching measure.”
All Life Institute scholars were an integral part of this coalition. Respected wildlife biologists, veterinarians, medical toxicologists, legal scholars and conservation professionals mobilized to communicate Amendment 83’s dangers.
This included an open letter on Oct. 22, 2026, from 21 bear biologists, wildlife scientists and conservation professionals warning about its threats to Colorado’s longstanding bear protections. Seven affiliated scholars signed the letter:
Simon Gadbois, Ph.D., Wildlife Ethology and Canine Olfaction Lab, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia;
Elaine Leslie, Ph.D., former chief, Biological Resources Division, National Park Service; executive council member, Coalition to Protect America’s National Parks;
Gordon M. Burghardt, Ph.D., Alumni Distinguished Service Professor Emeritus, University of Tennessee, Knoxville; former president, Animal Behavior Society; founding field chief editor, Frontiers in Ethology;
Jennifer Vonk, Ph.D., distinguished professor, Oakland University, Michigan; researcher in animal cognition and comparative psychology, including black and brown bears;
Gilbert Proulx, Ph.D., director of science, Alpha Wildlife Research & Management Ltd.; editor in chief, Canadian Wildlife Biology & Management;
Dan Doak, Ph.D., conservation biologist and population ecologist; professor and Byers Family Chair in Environmental Studies, University of Colorado Boulder; and
Jon Arnemo, Ph.D., wildlife veterinarian and professor, University of Inland Norway; researcher in wildlife management, ecotoxicology and lead exposure.
Seven human and wildlife health scientists from the Scholars’ Network also wrote individual letters citing how Amendment 83 would obstruct current efforts to phase out toxic lead ammunition in Colorado:
Dan Doak, Ph.D., professor, Department of Environmental Studies, University of Colorado Boulder;
Elaine Leslie, Ph.D., former chief, Biological Resources Division, National Park Service; executive council member, Coalition to Protect America’s National Parks;
Donald Smith, Ph.D., distinguished professor emeritus of microbiology and environmental toxicology, University of California, Santa Cruz;
Myra Finkelstein, Ph.D., adjunct professor of microbiology and environmental toxicology, University of California, Santa Cruz;
Mark A. Pokras, D.V.M., associate professor emeritus, Wildlife Clinic and Center for Conservation Medicine, Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine, Tufts University;
Michael J. Kosnett, M.D., M.P.H., associate adjunct professor, Department of Environmental and Occupational Health, Colorado School of Public Health;
Marc Bekoff, Ph.D., professor emeritus of ecology and evolutionary biology, University of Colorado Boulder.
A kaleidoscope of campaign strategies was in play simultaneously, which taken together delivered the win. We did the following:
1. Created a simple, powerful message for voters and delivered it through streaming advertising, social media ads and organic traffic, billboards, text messaging, earned media, and voter contact in the field.
We had a clear, compelling message: “Amendment 83 brings back steel-jawed traps, bear baiting,” practices Colorado voters had banned decades earlier. Rather than allowing proponents to frame the amendment as protecting hunting and fishing, we exposed its broader repercussions. As our advertising burned in, we heard voters on the streets repeating our message back to us.
Our digital TV ads generated 30 million impressions among a target audience of 2.7 million likely voters. We reinforced our messaging with 41 large billboards along the Front Range; sent more than 1 million text messages to targeted voters; and conducted a strong social media campaign.
We conducted an earned media campaign through press releases, blogs, expert commentary, opinion pieces and interviews.
We secured editorial support from major newspapers across Colorado, including The Denver Post, Daily Camera, Durango Herald and Grand Junction Daily Sentinel.
Gov. Polis, CPW commissioners and responsible hunting advocates also contributed opinion pieces to newspapers that reinforced our message.
2. Secured opposition from Colorado Parks and Wildlife commissioners.
We publicized opposition from six Colorado Parks and Wildlife commissioners, who spoke out independently against Amendment 83.
3. Built a broad, diverse coalition.
Among the organizations opposing Amendment 83 were the Sierra Club, Humane Colorado, Colorado Hunters and Anglers for Sensible Wildlife Conservation, Denver Audubon, Colorado Common Cause and the League of Women Voters of Colorado.
This wide-ranging support demonstrated that opposition was not only an animal welfare issue, but also a matter of science, responsible hunting and democratic governance.
4. Secured prominent political endorsements.
We obtained endorsements from Gov. Jared Polis, Attorney General and governor-elect Phil Weiser, and more than 50 state and federal lawmakers, including U.S. Reps. Jason Crow, Joe Neguse and Brittany Pettersen. These endorsements strengthened our campaign’s credibility and broadened its appeal to Colorado voters.
5. Educated voters along the Front Range.
We were actively in the field along the Front Range from Fort Collins to Colorado Springs, engaging directly with voters, handing out flyers, placing yard signs, holding banners, and educating constituents about the perils of Amendment 83.
6. Engaged donors and supporters.
Our donors’ contributions enabled us to support the campaign’s multichannel voter persuasion efforts.
The moral of our collective success story is that we accomplished this win together. It literally took all the moving pieces, people and strategies listed above to come together – combined with incredibly hard work and dedication – to achieve our desired outcome: a remarkable victory for wildlife protection in Colorado.
The defeat of Amendment 83 is a victory worth celebrating. And it is now a model for preempting similar constitutional amendment attempts from being enacted in other states.
